Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 December 2006

BT Vision IPTV services needs less BT and more vision

British telecom this week launched its hybrid IPTV service which marries DVB-T free to air services with a DSL broadband return path for VoD, voice and internet access. While this is mostly of interest only to UK readers, this launch also shows how Microsoft’s IPTV middleware performs in a hybrid, and opens up a surprise partnership between BT and Vodafone pointing to a European, and potentially global strategy, for Vodafone on video services.

Vodafone has already partnered with BT over broadband lines, and is now preparing to sell this BT Vision service as well. BT provides much of the UK backhaul for Vodafone and uses the Vodafone network as a basis for its own Mobile Virtual Network Operation (MVNO).

Vodafone is one of the few cellular operators that does not have much in the way of fixed lines, with the exception of its German Arcor subsidiary. Earlier this year it began to research the quadruple play through Arcor and has cut deals in France, Italy and the UK to offer fixed line services through partners.

But none so far have had a video element to them. Now it has revealed its hand in the BT launch and it might follow this up with a co-marketing deal with Fastweb in Italy for video, and possibly partner one of the local TV services in Germany, to add it to its Arcor network. However if the BT partnership goes well Vodafone could just as easily partner with other DVB-T hybrids across Europe which offer fixed line triple plays.

There are very few gains to be made by actually ‘owning’ fixed lines for a pure cellco play, since a quadruple play requires at least two network infrastructures, except where the service is pure wireless such as the one that Sprint is building in the US, so it looks like Vodafone will simply partner to create quad play packages.

The BT Vision IPTV service launched this week has been so long in gestation that it was launched primarily as a churn stopper to slow the departure of customers leaving BT to go to either BSkyB or NTL/Virgin Media.

Back in the mid 1990s when the concept of replay TV plus movies over a broadband line was first posited as a killer app, the world was a very different place. There was no DVB-T service in the UK, now there are 8.6 million customers on the free to air Freeview.

Satellite TV provider BSkyB was in its infancy, offering analog services to under 1 million customers, while cable operators languished, underfunded, and unloved by the public.

Today by BTs own admission that this has changed (see graph) and the overwhelming conclusion of the launch is that BT is now responding with an across the board defense of its realm ‘ the fixed line and all that can go down it.

Both Sky and NTL Virgin are attacking, with Sky offering content over broadband to the PC, and cheap or free broadband lines, Voice over IP and TV content. It also has some element of Video on Demand, but not to the TV, only to the PC so far.

This all became possible when Sky bought Easynet and got into the unbundled loop business (it also sells BT wholesale broadband lines) which meant it could offer a triple play in the UK at least, as a pioneer for News Corp’s global entertainment services push.

Virgin NTL can’t really offer VoIP as yet, as much of its network is analog, but it can offer it on unbundled BT broadband lines, so it can effectively compete in the triple play market and of course it offers a T-Mobile based MVNO for mobile, so it contributes to fixed voice erosion by mobile substitution.

Slowly BT has pieced together a strategy that might, just might, hold all that at bay. The BT Fusion phone introduced last June offers a cellphone that defaults to the home hub and VoIP when in range of the home, and offers cheap voice at 5.5p (10 Cents) for up to an hour, and now it adds BT Vision to that.

But for all of its claims about it reinventing TV, the minimum charge of £15 ($29.65) a month for broadband, plus the all you can eat value pack for a subscription to VoD at £14 ($27.65), means that it is going up against Sky and Virgin with a triple play that is roughly the same cost as the two major incumbents. There are extra charges for VoIP and cellular, which include evenings and weekend home calls for free.

This pricing doesn’t give it an appreciable advantage over Sky or cable and by BT’s own calculations the top end TV services for each player are £379 a year for BT Vision ($749), £446 rising to £610 for Sky ($881 to $1,205) and £434 for cable ($858). Given that the only advantage is a credible VoD system, with a DVR, but that BT is only offering TV channels that are free to air, this doesn’t seem to be cheap enough to us to ensure success.

Unfortunately all of that just gives VoD for music, kids programming and past TV series and Replay TV, not films, which can only be bought on a pay per view basis. Also the Replay TV at present only includes Channel 4, and deals with ITV and the BBC are expected to get the go ahead in the next few months.

Customers can buy less if they prefer, for instance they can buy each TV series replay pay per view, or buy films for £1.99 up to £2.99 ($3.90 to $5.90). Or they can only pay for TV replay for just £3 ($6) a month.

Replay TV is like having an EPG that can go backwards as well as forwards and allows viewers to watch programming that they have missed from any time during the past week. In effect it is a network DVR and IPTV services such as Homechoice in the UK, now owned by Tiscali, already have this feature and it works with virtually all the channels. BT is merely promising it.

All of this means that BT’s revolution in TV is not very revolutionary and it was no wonder that it led its launch with the all important soccer coverage that has dominated the UK market. Sky clearly doesn’t feel threatened by this service, so much so that it has co-bid with BT for sports rights and as a result BT Vision has 242 Premiership soccer games throughout the season that it has paid for, and now adds to that 46 of the top premiership games, and the Scottish Premierleague by dint of a separate deal done with Setanta sports, an independent sports TV service. But given that Setanta already provides events to 100 million digital TV homes worldwide and 1,500 bars and clubs, it’s not as if this content is exclusive.

So BT’s message seems to be, buy BT Vision, we’ve got football, and while this was the formula that rocketed Sky to the top of the pay TV charts in the UK, BT Vision cannot claim the same type of exclusivity that Sky once had when it was pioneering.

But surely the natty Microsoft EPG design and the fact that the service has pure IP pumping through its veins, count for something. Well it might, but not yet.

Much of the announcement was about what BT does NOT have rather than what it has working so far.

On content is has 1,000 films, but it plans to have 5,000. The current films come from Disney, Warner and Paramount, but there is currently a complete absence among the major studios of 20th Century Fox (a sister service to Sky in the News Corp fold) and Sony Pictures.

So while BT might have a temporary edge in films over satellite, it has missing quite a lot of the VoD content that Virgin Media will have, courtesy of a deal it did with On Demand TV, which includes films from all the major Hollywood studios.

And even this film content is released in the Pay per view window, whereas its parallel download to PC service gets the films that much earlier in the DVD sales window, but these cannot be played on a TV as yet.

This will change over time as devices emerge to allow easy connection between the PC and the TV set, but once this happens, all of those download to PC services that are out there will also rival BT, with films that are newer.

Okay the VoD service is real time, switch it on like a lightswitch and watch, whereas PC downloading services tend to have a built in download delay. This is due to the fact that BT has built complex quality of service protocols into its data management that ensure that the on demand video gets across its network as a priority. Other services will not be able to do this and will have patchy file delivery and have to download a decent amount of a video file to their PC before beginning to watch it.

At the launch BT made great play out of this but kept asking ‘Why would you send broadcast TV over your broadband line?’ as if their logic was somehow compelling. There is a lot of confusion here, mostly among the BT staff. BT feels it cannot compete with DVB-T free to air services with an IP multicast set up, and that’s right. But a single DVB-T Freeview multiplex of 40 broadcast channels fails to live up to the multiple hundreds of channels that Sky offers on its satellite service.

Many of these channels, comedy, film and action channels are pure US content, available to BT if it had a multicast, and it is these which drive the subscription services of Sky and which are NOT available as free to air programming, simply because they are too expensive and exclusive to distribute in that way.

No, the real reason for not offering IPTV multicasts is so that BT does not have to rebuild its DSLAM network, which is one of the oldest in Europe, and which reaches the largest percentage of exchanges of any network in Europe. Backhauling 350 Mbps of video data to each of its exchanges and offering a multicast router network wasn’t the problem, it was the fact it would have had to gone head to head with Sky, and yet it needed Sky as a content partner, so it couldn’t.

So elsewhere in Europe it will be the politics of the incumbent networks, the penetration of DVB-T and the depth of market control exercised by cable and satellite pay TV rivals, which will decide on precise incumbent offerings. It’s not out of any innate technology advantages of hybrid DVB-T systems.

The other things that Microsoft middleware SHOULD give an incumbent, but which BT has yet to launch, including integration with the TV of the VoIP service (caller ID flashing on the TV screen for incoming calls etc’) They also include video conferencing on the TV, instant messaging, sharing photos, gaming, gambling, interactive retail, program voting and user generated content uploading. These were all NOT launched by BT, but were all promised.

Also the idea of transferring TV programs, or even films, to portable devices for viewing later on the portable or viewing on a different screen (your PC at work, your laptop, the TV in your friend’s house) is completely missing from this TV vision. BT told us several years ago that this was one of the reasons for choosing Microsoft in the first place, because of its ever present DRM software.

Well this turned out not to be true, and while the Microsoft PC continues to have a free bundled DRM component, it has singularly failed to get its portable devices which also incorporate the same DRM elements, to ship in volumes. What BT and others need is a way of transferring content to a mobile phone, and to that end it doesn’t need Windows Media DRM but one of the two flavors of DRM from the Open Mobile Alliance or from the DVB Project, which are forming the basis of DRM for mobile TV.

With just 3% of mobile devices running a Microsoft platform (perhaps rising to 6% over the next two years) this limits BT and others like it to selling their own mobile platform for viewing TV programs, something that has singularly failed elsewhere in the world.

Microsoft, it may be argued, are big enough to fight these battles for them, and it may well offer a Windows Media DRM translation into OMA on the near horizon, but if it tactically doesn’t suit Microsoft to do this, then that will leave operators tied into their own limited device regime.

Now if Apple would release its own IPTV middleware, then programs could copy to an iPod from this and everyone would be happy.

Another thing missing from the service, but alluded to as something that BT plans to go after, is niche content. Here it will chase existing .tv internet TV channels and specialist production teams and is actively campaigning for specialist magazines to create their own TV channels. These are far easier to deliver as a VoD service to a few thousand customers, than they are as a broadcast service, and again BT didn’t launch this, but is planning it.

This whole new service will cut a £100 million hole in BT’s profits next year, and is not going to be a money spinner for BT for three years, by which time, in the words of Dan Marks, CEO of BT Vision, the service will have several million customers. Well if it takes 2 to 3 million customers for this to be profitable, there is certainly a danger that it will never be profitable. This just shows that the service is instrumental in churn reduction, and in our view is not actually expected to make real money. Even with 2 million homes paying £14 a month for 12 months, that would only put just over £300 million on the revenue table for BT, less than 2% of its total business.

Perhaps when all those services that BT hasn’t yet launched are in play, the consumer services will add up to a whole lot more. But then again because BT is too cautious and steady for its own good, by the time they are launched, other services may have swept past them.