Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 November 2012

DVB passes ‘pointless’ NGH TV standard that cellcos will ignore

As expected the Steering Board of the DVB project has approved the new DVB-NGH (next generation handheld) specification at its latest meeting held this week.

This is a standard, based on DVB-T2 which when seen alongside developments in the 3GPP standards base, may finally create an avalanche of content delivery over cellular to handsets. Even if it does it will have been a long road and the unmitigated disaster of the DVB-H specification, that ate literally years of market lead in Europe and eventually led to broadcast TV to a handset becoming a dirty word, may be forgotten. But we don’t think so.

There are a bewildering number of technical improvements, but none of them address the key issue ‘ that of business model. Today the world universally accepts that the way to get video to a portable device, be it a tablet or a smartphone or even a handheld gaming device, is to send it over WiFi.

Now we know that this is effectively a blind alley, because people are often in the mood for entertainment on their portable devices specifically when they are out of range of WiFi. Which brings streaming video delivery down to the cellular network and we have visited this time and time again. That may be widely possible once LTE Advanced is widely installed, but not before. Most mobile TV options are deeply unsatisfying when they are delivered over cellular. This is usually because the amount of money paid for voice services is so high, that it has to take priority and this usually means that once 20 people are attached to a base station watching TV, albeit at a relatively low SD resolution on a smaller screen, say 4 inches diagonally like the new iPhone 5, then no more video signals can be allowed from that base station, since either the voice services will begin to suffer, or other data such as HTML web files will be shut off for everyone in reach of that base station.

The weight of video has led Cisco in its visual networking index to estimate that cellular networks will carry 10.5 Exabytes of data a month by 2016, with over 70% of that being video. (An Exabyte is 1,000 petabytes, which is 1,000 terabytes, which is 1,000 gigabytes) But the truth is that if that actually happens, it will block other, relatively more profitable services such as mobile gaming and mobile advertising.

The laws of physics point to broadcast services at some stage bearing the burden of this type of content delivery instead, but outside of Japan, where this is an everyday thing for 80 million people, and South Korea, where half the population watches linear TV on their phones, and among a small minority in China, broadcast TV on phones is almost laughed at.

It’s not consumers that doesn’t like it, it’s the inability of the operator to deliver that type of service and do it both risk free (with no extra cost) and to make money out of it.

DVB-H was a protocol where the network owner had to first get a new piece of spectrum, then build a brand new network, for something like $200 million (3 Italia built one that cost this but only attracted under 1 million users). Also the receiver chips were expensive since they did not have other applications, and in volume they still added $8 or so to the Bill of Materials on a phone. Phone vendors were unsure of their ability to pass that on to the operator, and operators found that consumers would prefer a phone that had TV, but would not pay extra for one, or at least not much or not many of them.

So the key to breaking this deadlock is to bring linear TV and non-linear video to the handset in such a way that it fits in with the existing broadcast infrastructure, so the handset needs no new radio or chip added to it in order to take advantage of the service, and bring such high quality content that cellular operators can charge for it.

The low appetite for solving that combination of problems has meant no-one has been interested for some time, and ATSC M/H, an extension of the US digital terrestrial broadcasting system has solved many of those problems, but so far, only one small cellular operator, MetroPCS, has added any devices to its catalog that can view the 70 or so services around the US, with one popular handset, a Samsung Galaxy, including a receiver chip in it. It announced it would do this last Janaury and delivered in only in August and has yet to tell anyone how much demand there is for it. The phones can only get 5 TV channels in any given market. The rest of the US sits and waits. Before cellular operators move aggressively on this there will need to be a lot more channels we suspect.

The new NGH specification really only gets DVB operators to the same point as ATSC M/H in the US. Most DVB broadcasters are in Europe and it is here that no-one has had a conspicuous broadcast mobile TV success. DVB-NGH is based on DVB-T2, with additional MIMO, added Time Frequency Slicing and the use of non-uniform constellations, and better LDPC codes. All that means is that the signal will be clearer, more reliable and penetrate walls better.

The new system can also allow a satellite and terrestrial signal to complement and boost one another (something that China insisted upon when it designed CMMB, but then never used), so there is the potential for delivery of a high quality video signal both indoors and outdoors.

The specification will be submitted immediately to ETSI the European standards institute and no doubt there will be a standard issued. But will anyone ever user it?

Well broadcasters will almost certainly experiment with it and offer trial signals and perhaps like in the US, buy the relatively cheap digital exciters that will be needed to lay the mobile signal across existing spectrum, from existing transmitters and using existing antennas. But that’s not enough.

DVB makes the same point itself in the release when it says, ‘Since the introduction of DVB-H, significant changes have taken place in the delivery and consumption of multimedia content. Initially, DVB-H was launched to provide linear broadcast services for handheld devices. However, the multimedia content market is going through a profound change from traditional linear content consumption to a wide range of rich media content consumption. This rich media includes traditional TV (linear), various video and audio content, images and text messages as well as push download to local memory in the receiver. The delivery of the content has to keep pace with the user’s demand and user’s behavior. DVB-NGH is designed to be the ideal solution for broadcast content delivery to handheld and mobile devices for the next decade.’

Since then the denser DVB-T2 has been launched in 2008, a Lite version of it came out last year, which could send a signal to a handset, alongside an HD version to a TV. NGH is a way of making that signal easier to pick up at the handset.

Faultline wrote a requiem for the DVB-H technology in 2008 in a piece entitled ‘DVB-H hanging on by its fingertips’ and again in 2010 asked, ‘Is DVB-H the one case where Euthanasia is justified’

At that time we counted a live system in Africa, in Kenya, Nigeria, Namibia, and a Government mandated system coming in South Africa, a live service in Vietnam, one in Latvia, as many as four promised in the Philippines which all slowly lost momentum and died, a Doordashan trial running from 2006 for four years in India, and trials which seem to indicate that services would happen in Indonesia, Ireland and in countries as diverse as Libya, Malaysia and Poland. It’s a poor showing with the UK, France, Germany, Spain, Portugal Austria, and most of Scandinavia, Benelux and much of central Europe all glad they never went down the DVB-H route or have tried and pulled out of a move that might have cost anything between $200 million and $500 million per country depending on its size and how it was deployed.

Suggesting that this scenario is all back on once again would be foolhardy. The moves need to be underpinned by commitment by the companies that pay for devices, the cellcos, and so far they have been continuously and aggressively against broadcast content getting to phones ‘ and once again they cite the business model issues.

Business models such as live sports broadcasting on a box office basis have been suggested, as well as hybrids where linear TV is broadcast, and a network PVR copy of that content is sold as a subscription, and streamed to phones which have missed it. As handsets gain more and more flash memory the idea that streaming movies can be stored on the phone using push VoD has become possible. But if that’s possible why not copy them from your DVR before you leave home? This type of DVR application was never focused on in previous generations of broadcast mobile TV, because the signal reliability was not there. It ended up with handsets capturing most of a TV program but failing to record some vital part because the phone went through a tunnel or into a building when that part was being transmitted. With a more robust signal that issue may go away somewhat.

We would expect DVB- NGH will go to trials in 2013, led by broadcasters in one of the many countries currently installing DVB- T2 transmitters. But cellcos may not necessarily follow, and someone has to pay for an extra broadcast receiver chip to be built into portable devices, whether they are TV sets, tablets or smartphones.

Given the current route to market for TV services of creating an App and assuming that the consumer will find his or her way to a Wifi connection, we cannot see this new standard changing that style of thinking within cellular operators. We may not agree with those operators, but historically that’s their position and we cannot see enough of a compelling reason here to make it change.

The fundamental rules of physics are that a single signal transmitting to everyone takes up an order of magnitude less bandwidth than each person having their own separate video feed, but as the global fixed broadband network heads to the type of capacity which could feed every one of the world’s 1.5 billion TV sets out there with an IP driven broadband HD signal, video will virtually become resident within the broadband network on CDNs.

If cellular operators wanted to offer a hybrid between broadcast and unicast video feeds, which would help them accommodate the delivery of video, like a major sporting event, to tens of thousands of phones, then there are existing tools for this. eMBMS (Evolved Multimedia Broadcast and Multicast Services) is built into LTE and companies like Qualcomm, Huawei and Ericsson have put all their effort into this. We expect that more and more LTE chips will simply be able to receive an MBMS signal, because it is broadcast in part of the licensed cellular spectrum, so no extra radio or tuning is needed.

The difficulty has been designing a software layer for the base station that effectively grabs the same piece of spectrum for say a football match, in each of all the neighboring base station cells, and co-ordinates its use. Effectively cellular operators want a system that scales from the very first person who tunes into a TV channel, which would be delivered as unicast stream. As more people request the same channel, initially this means more unicast streams are set running. But after say ten such requests the base station they are in decides to turn this into a single multicast system, it combines all the unicasts into one broadcast and tells the phones to shift to it.

When neighboring cell sites experience the same demand they all co-ordinate and use the same spectrum, and then the cellular networks behaves just like a DVB-NGH signal, a single frequency network where each base station boosts the robustness of an identical signal with the same timing.

There are those who think that NGH can also be part of this, and that there can be broadcast TV across a country, multicast TV in one or a handful of base stations, and unicast to everyone else and each TV channel can find its right level. But our thoughts are that if cellular operators decided to go this route they will wait until eMBMS is mature and use a pure 3GPP set of standards, leaving free to air broadcasters to send out a signal that no-one cares to listen to because they have so little influence in the creation of consumer electronics devices.

We’d go so far as cellular operators then leasing their capacity back to free to air broadcasters if they want to put their TV channels over the cellular signal, and leave it to the free to air broadcasters to pay for it out of increased advertising potential. Subscriptions would go the same way for pay TV operators, that way the cellcos take no risks at all.

In fact there is one movement in France that says that the two protocols can be merged. In other words the modulation on the signals in eMBMS can be identical to those in the broadcast. While the two camps use different spectrum, you might look for a channel on the cellular offering of TV channels, and it may notice that this channel is also broadcasting on a nearby piece of UHF spectrum and it can offload the job to that, all done in software. This idea has been backed by Orange, Alcatel, CNES (the French space agency), DiBcom, Mitsubishi, Teamcast, INSA-IETR and Telecom Bretagne.

It sounds far-fetched and a typically French piece of collaboration to us, and perhaps unworkable in the near future or outside France, but we hold out little hope outside of a few isolated countries like Finland, for a pure DVB-NGH service to be launched with any prospect of large scale success, without the help of a cellular operator. And we still do not see that help coming.