Californian research outfit iSuppli has taken apart a Toshiba $500 High Definition DVD player and found that its component parts can only be bought for $674, and that figure doesn’t count costs for manufacturing, testing, cables, remote control and packaging.
The suggestion is that Toshiba is trying to buy the market, especially given that it has no handy way to claw back the subsidies. And since it is trying to dominate a new consumer electronics category, it has to be asked whether or not this is strictly legal? Perhaps someone will ask the US Justice Department of the European Commission for an opinion on that.
iSuppli dissected the Toshiba new HD-A1 HD-DVD and it reckons that with the additional costs counted in, the real price might be over $700.
Given that retailers must have a margin on the sale of these devices, the subsidy could be substantially more than $200 per device.
The move is designed to win market share over the rival Blu-ray high-definition DVD standard led by Sony and backed by companies like Samsung and Matsushita. By comparison these are hitting the market at around $1,000.
The HD-A1 has an Intel Pentium 4 processor, a Broadcom BCM7411 High-Definition video decoder, four DSPs from Analog Devices totaling $137 on the volume merchant market. It also uses $125 of memory with chips from Hynix, M-Systems and Spansion.
Subsidies go on in mobile phone handsets, by operators, not manufacturers, and in games consoles, where the shortfall is clawed back through lucrative future content sales. But these seems little point in doing in for a consumer electronics device except to undermine the market unfairly.