Last week we attended the Connected TV World Summit in London. On the second day we went to the breakout session called ‘Owning the Connected Home,’ ready to hear how connected TV players intended to address the smart home of the future. Unfortunately for us, the session barely addressed the smart/connected home and if the panel was a sign of the confidence that pay TV operators have in the connected home of the future, the pay TV industry risks letting its privileged position slip away to new entrants to the sector.
The first of two presentations was led by Alan Smith of DirecTV who recapped and outlined the DirecTV whole-home DVR strategy. The Genie set top has five tuners to support four concurrent TVs at a time, with 1TB of storage that can record 5 channels simultaneously. The Genie handles all of the recording centrally before sending the recorded show to the other connected TVs in the home, solving the problem of managing multiple recording schedules.
DirecTV supplies a mini set top to connect the other TVs, the C31 Genie Mini Client, which connects to the master DVR using DECA (DirecTV Ethernet Coaxial Adapter), or the newer wireless version (C41W). The wireless version provides an easier installation for homes that lack coaxial wiring in every room, as the Quantenna supplied 4×4 802.11n MIMO chip should enable a high-bandwidth connection that only requires a power supply and HDMI out to the TV.
Additional TVs can be connected without using the C41W or C31, using RVU compatible devices. The RVU Alliance was set up to provide interoperability between RVU compliant devices ‘ technology based on client-server relationships that is used to provide live and recorded TV across devices in a consistent UI. DLNA and UPnP compatible, the RVU Alliance was founded by DirecTV, Broadcom, Cisco and Samsung. The alliance claims over 20 million RVU compliant devices have been sold in the US, from the likes of Humax, Pace, Samsung, Sharp, Sony and Technicolor.
But while Smith’s recap was concise and focused, it wasn’t quite what the session promised; that is DirecTV certainly outlined and reaffirmed its plan for connected TVs in the home, but we didn’t gain any insight into the company’s plan for ‘Owning the Connected Home.’
We asked Smith if DirecTV was working on a complete home automation package, on the grounds that the Genie is perfectly positioned as a dedicated hub to manage a connected home ecosystem. Smith responded by pointing out the acquisition of LifeShield last year, a company which provides home security using DECT to communicate with motion sensors and wireless WiFi cameras for remote monitoring.
At the time, DirecTV said that it had opted to buy the company outright instead of partnering with it ‘because over time, DirecTV wants to fully integrate the home security technology into the DirecTV video experience.’ We also thought that Smith’s delivery of ‘nothing publicly in development’ somewhat implied DirecTV was indeed working on a smart home platform, but we’ll have to wait and see ‘ especially in light of AT&T’s offer to buy DirecTV, on which Smith said he categorically would not comment.
The lack of smart home discussion was not addressed by the next speaker in the session. Although Polish pay TV company NC+’s Wojciech Bialek was thoroughly entertaining, in particular his suggestion for an alternative translation of OTT more fitting for its use (On The Toilet) which drew the mirth of the audience; his discussion of the complexities of home PVRs in the Polish market was interesting but not really what we hoped to get from the ‘Owning the Connected Home’ session.
So we had high hopes for the final panel of the session, in which we anticipated a round-table discussion of how pay TV would enter the smart home market. Unfortunately, we got no such thing, and this annoyed us.
Chaired by Tricia Parks of Parks Associates, the panel featured John Civiletto, Vice President of Technology Strategic Architecture at Cox Communications; Eric Budin, the Vice President of Product Strategy and Incubation at Liberty Global; Roberto Pellegrini, Vice President of Strategic Marketing at ADB; and Steve Christian, Vice President of Marketing and Product Management at Verimatrix.
What followed was a fairly disjointed discussion of the ‘Technology that will shape the Pay TV connected home.’ Between the panelists, we heard that MoCA could form the backbone of a connected home network, which is only really an option in the US, where there are sufficient numbers of homes that are wired with coaxial cable throughout ‘ something not found in much of Europe, Africa, Latin America or Asia.
We also heard that increasing the bandwidth of the home network was a priority for the smart home, and that home gateways and routers could be used to prioritize connected home traffic. Both these ideas are sufficiently obvious to not merit a full panel discussion, but we would have enjoyed a detailed debate about the merits of either connection methodology. We got neither, instead hearing more about the rather mundane task of connecting TVs in different rooms of a house.
In fact, so little of the panel’s conversation was noteworthy (in the truest sense of the word) and the overall tone so unenthusiastic that the session left quite a sour taste in the mouth. Looking back at the notes we took, it’s hard for us to justify the logistical expense of bringing the panel together in the first place, considering that the conversation only briefly touched on the smart home as a product and gave very little insight into the strategy of pay TV operators and their intended approach ‘ other than the rather obvious facts that CPE and an internet connection were important to deployments.
All in all, the overwhelming show of un-enthusiasm for a market that is expected to be worth in excess of a trillion dollars by 2020 typifies the atrophy that pay TV seems to be experiencing worldwide, as subscribers jump ship to cheaper OTT offerings while the operators prefer to merge instead of innovating. It’s a sort of economic conservatism that sees them losing ground to other smart home players, despite their hugely advantageous position.
Both pay TV operators and ISPs are uniquely placed to win the smart home fight for consumers before it has really begun in earnest. They each use a subscription model that leases equipment to the consumer. Since the biggest obstacle to a consumer kitting their home out in smart home gear is the price tag, which could easily run into four figures for the minimum store-bought spec that would be considered comprehensive, the TV and internet providers can massively reduce the expense that a consumer would have to endure to attain a smart home ‘ thanks to their established CPE presence in the home and the subscription model that lessens the blow to the consumer’s finances.
And some providers seem to be slowly waking up to this fact. Most of the US pay TV operators are offering a home security package alongside their primary offering. Home security is disproportionately valued by consumers in the US compared to the rest of the world, but it is a product that could be sold to any developed economy. Logical deviations from this TV/Internet + Security model would add HVAC and lighting automation, perhaps later automation in the kitchen for both preparing and replenishing food stocks in the home. The technology is ready now and only needs to be brought to market in a convenient package to start winning over consumers. If the 4 pay TV insiders on the panel are typical of the industry as a whole, then pay TV is almost certainly going to let its head start be eroded by the likes of Apple and Google in the smart home.